Clinical trial / 1984
Substituting beef protein for 55% of plant proteins raised HDL cholesterol without significantly changing total or LDL cholesterol in healthy young men.
Eight healthy normolipidemic men consumed a plant protein diet and an animal protein diet (beef protein replacing 55% of plant protein) in a 21-day crossover trial. There were no statistically significant differences in mean serum total cholesterol or plasma LDL cholesterol between diets. Mean plasma HDL cholesterol was significantly higher at day 21 on the animal protein diet (48 +/- 3 mg/dl) versus the plant protein diet (42 +/- 2 mg/dl, p < 0.05). Mean serum triglycerides were significantly higher at day 7 on the plant protein diet (136 +/- 19 mg/dl) compared to the animal protein diet (84 +/- 12 mg/dl, p < 0.05).
NANO COUNTERPOINT
On meat and poultry
We keep this study as published. Here is the other evidence behind NANO's stance.
- Trial results on red meat depend on what it's compared with. A meta-analysis of randomized trials found that replacing red meat with high-quality plant protein foods led to more favorable blood lipid changes, while swapping in fish or low-quality carbohydrates did not.Guasch-Ferré M, Satija A, Blondin SA et al. Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials of Red Meat Consumption in Comparison With Various Comparison Diets on Cardiovascular Risk Factors. Circulation, 2019. PMID 30958719
- In pooled US cohorts, higher intake of processed meat, unprocessed red meat or poultry was associated with a small increase in cardiovascular disease risk.Zhong VW, Van Horn L, Greenland P et al. Associations of Processed Meat, Unprocessed Red Meat, Poultry, or Fish Intake With Incident Cardiovascular Disease and All-Cause Mortality. JAMA internal medicine, 2020. PMID 32011623
- In two large cohorts, replacing animal protein with plant protein was associated with lower mortality, especially when replacing processed red meat.Song M, Fung TT, Hu FB et al. Association of Animal and Plant Protein Intake With All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality. JAMA internal medicine, 2016. PMID 27479196
- Study type
- Crossover trial
- Who was studied
- Eight healthy normolipidemic men aged 18 to 27 years
- What was measured
- Serum total cholesterol, triglycerides, plasma LDL cholesterol, and HDL cholesterol
THE PAPER
A comparison of the effect of diets containing beef protein and plant proteins on blood lipids of healthy young men.
Wiebe SL, Bruce VM, McDonald BE. Am J Clin Nutr, 1984.
This note is written from the study's published abstract. It summarizes what the authors reported; it is not medical advice and does not replace reading the full paper.