INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Gut Microbiome / Health Desk

Whole grains, stool acids and a modest microbiome effect

A weight-maintenance feeding trial separated stool and microbial findings from inflammation claims.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

A controlled six-week substitution

After a two-week provided-food run-in, 49 men and 32 postmenopausal women were assigned to whole-grain-rich or refined-grain weight-maintenance diets for six weeks. Participants were 40 to 65 years old and had body mass index below 35. Providing food and maintaining body weight made this a useful test of the grain substitution rather than an intentional weight-loss program. The investigators measured gut microbiota, microbial products, and immune and inflammatory responses. This was a whole-grain dietary comparison, however, not an experiment isolating a single fiber molecule or testing a specific home-cooked grain recipe.

Vanegas SM, Meydani M, Barnett JB, Goldin B et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2017. PMID 28179226 · DOI

Stool outcomes were clearer than a sweeping claim

Compared with the refined-grain group, the whole-grain group had increased stool weight and frequency, with P values below 0.0001 and 0.02, respectively. Changes in stool acetate were also higher in the whole-grain group, at P=0.02, while the comparison for total short-chain fatty acids was P=0.05. These findings describe measured stool endpoints over six weeks. They should not be translated into a percentage improvement in gut health, a claim about circulating short-chain fatty acids or a demonstrated reduction in disease. The abstract does not provide numerical concentration changes from which to calculate such effects.

Vanegas SM, Meydani M, Barnett JB, Goldin B et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2017. PMID 28179226 · DOI

Read the microbial statistics carefully

The abstract reports increased Lachnospira and decreased Enterobacteriaceae in the whole-grain group, but gives false-discovery-rate-corrected P values of 0.25 for both comparisons. Those values warrant caution rather than a confident claim that these bacterial groups changed. Associations between Lachnospira and acetate or butyrate had smaller corrected P values, 0.002 and 0.005, respectively. An association between a bacterial measure and a stool metabolite does not establish that the bacterium caused a clinical benefit. The paper's own description of modest microbiome effects is a better guide than a dramatic account of a transformed microbial community.

Vanegas SM, Meydani M, Barnett JB, Goldin B et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2017. PMID 28179226 · DOI

The inflammation headline needs restraint

The investigators reported selected immune-response differences, including a higher percentage of terminal effector memory T cells and higher stimulated ex vivo tumor necrosis factor-alpha production. But their conclusion also states that other markers of cell-mediated immunity and systemic and gut inflammation did not change. This is not evidence that six weeks of whole grains broadly suppressed inflammation. The trial involved healthy adults on weight-maintenance diets, not a treatment study for inflammatory bowel disease. A grain-based dish fits the food theme, but the trial cannot assign its measured stool or immune effects to that particular recipe.

Vanegas SM, Meydani M, Barnett JB, Goldin B et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2017. PMID 28179226 · DOI