INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Nutrition & Adequacy / Health Desk

Walnuts and cognition: the two-year trial was null overall

A site-specific signal did not overturn the randomized trial’s primary cognitive result.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

A longer trial with a defined primary endpoint

The Walnuts And Healthy Aging trial randomly assigned 708 cognitively healthy adults aged 63 to 79 to a walnut-enriched diet or a control diet avoiding walnuts. The intervention supplied approximately 15% of energy from walnuts, or 30 to 60 grams daily, for two years. Participants lived freely rather than remaining in a feeding center. The primary outcome was change in a global cognitive composite derived from a neurocognitive test battery. This was a test of cognitive performance over time, not a trial demonstrating prevention or treatment of dementia.

Sala-Vila A, Valls-Pedret C, Rajaram S, Coll-Padrós N, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2020. PMID 31912155 · DOI

The overall comparison was not significant

A total of 636 participants completed the intervention, and the modified intention-to-treat analysis included 657. The mean change in the global cognitive composite was minus 0.072 in the walnut group and minus 0.086 in controls. The between-group comparison was not statistically significant, with P equal to 0.491. Small numerical separation should not be presented as a demonstrated cognitive benefit. The abstract’s overall conclusion is that two years of walnut supplementation had no effect on cognition in these healthy older adults, even though additional analyses generated questions worth studying further.

Sala-Vila A, Valls-Pedret C, Rajaram S, Coll-Padrós N, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2020. PMID 31912155 · DOI

The Barcelona finding was post hoc

Participants were recruited in Barcelona and Loma Linda. The Barcelona group had lower baseline neuropsychological scores, less education, and more smoking than the Loma Linda group. A post hoc analysis found a significant walnut-control difference within Barcelona, while brain imaging in a subset produced additional functional findings. These analyses are not the same as the prespecified overall cognitive comparison. The abstract explicitly calls their implications encouraging but inconclusive. A headline about universal cognitive protection would give the subgroup finding more authority than the primary randomized result and omit the sites’ baseline differences.

Sala-Vila A, Valls-Pedret C, Rajaram S, Coll-Padrós N, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2020. PMID 31912155 · DOI

Keep an appealing food separate from a claim

The abstract reports good compliance and that walnuts were well tolerated, but those observations do not change the cognitive result. The authors propose further investigation in populations that may be at greater risk; they do not establish benefit in those populations through this trial. A walnut-containing breakfast is relevant to the ingredient, not proof of a brain-health effect or delivery of the assigned daily amount. The careful takeaway is a genuine null overall result with exploratory site-specific signals, rather than a recommendation to use walnuts to prevent cognitive decline.

Sala-Vila A, Valls-Pedret C, Rajaram S, Coll-Padrós N, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2020. PMID 31912155 · DOI