Lutein-rich greens: the eye-pigment trial that stayed null
Two short randomized pilot studies caution against equating carotenoid intake with a proven macular benefit.

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.
A direct food comparison
Graydon and colleagues conducted two eight-week pilot intervention studies in healthy volunteers to compare carotenoid-rich foods and supplements. In the food study, 52 participants were randomized to carrot juice, described as carotene-rich, or spinach powder, described as lutein- and zeaxanthin-rich. The supplement study enrolled 75 participants and used a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled design with lutein and zeaxanthin, beta-carotene, or placebo. These were related but separate experiments, not one large trial of fresh leafy greens. Their small size, short duration, and healthy study populations are important boundaries when interpreting what they can say about eye-related outcomes or a long-term eating pattern.
Graydon R, Hogg RE, Chakravarthy U, Young IS et al.. The British journal of nutrition, 2012. PMID 22313522 · DOI
The primary message was no significant effect
Neither intervention study found a significant effect on macular pigment level over eight weeks. The investigators also found no effects on the measured serological markers of endothelial activation, inflammation, or oxidation. Those included C-reactive protein and F2-isoprostanes, alongside other circulating measurements. For an article about lutein-rich greens, the null macular result belongs in the foreground rather than a footnote. This experiment does not justify promising that adding spinach will measurably increase macular pigment within two months. Equally, the result should retain its setting: it concerns these pilot interventions in healthy volunteers, not every possible food, duration, or population that could be studied.
Graydon R, Hogg RE, Chakravarthy U, Young IS et al.. The British journal of nutrition, 2012. PMID 22313522 · DOI
Correlations do not overturn the group result
The abstract reports associations between changes in serum carotenoids and macular pigment among participants receiving lutein- and zeaxanthin-rich foods or supplements. For lutein, the correlation was 0.40 with P of 0.05 in the food study and 0.43 with P of 0.03 in the supplement study. The corresponding zeaxanthin associations were weaker, with P values of 0.14 and 0.28. These response correlations are not the same result as a significant intervention effect. They may help motivate questions about variation between individuals, but they do not replace the trial's overall finding that the interventions did not significantly change macular pigment level over eight weeks.
Graydon R, Hogg RE, Chakravarthy U, Young IS et al.. The British journal of nutrition, 2012. PMID 22313522 · DOI
Pigment is not a prevention outcome
Change in macular pigment level was inversely associated with baseline pigment level in both studies: the reported correlations were −0.54 in the food study and −0.40 in the supplement study, both with P below 0.001. The authors suggested possible improvement in those with initially low levels or the highest serum responses, while still concluding that the overall interventions had no significant effect. These subgroup-oriented observations warrant restraint. The abstract reports pigment and circulating markers, not an outcome showing prevention of age-related macular degeneration or preserved vision. A meal can feature leafy greens without being presented as a treatment whose clinical eye benefits were established by this short pilot research.
Graydon R, Hogg RE, Chakravarthy U, Young IS et al.. The British journal of nutrition, 2012. PMID 22313522 · DOI