INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Nutrition & Adequacy / Health Desk

Prunes and hip density: the lower dose had the clearer trial result

A year-long trial measured preservation of hip bone density, not observed fracture prevention.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

A bone question rather than a bowel question

The Prune Study randomized 235 postmenopausal women to a control group or to 50 or 100 grams of prunes daily for 12 months. Their average age was about 62 years. Investigators measured bone mineral density every six months and also assessed bone biomarkers. This is a different research question from trials of prunes for constipation. The relevant population, exposure, and endpoint all belong in the headline: postmenopausal women consuming measured prune amounts, with bone density followed over a year rather than bowel symptoms recorded over several weeks.

De Souza MJ, Strock NCA, Williams NI, Lee H, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2022. PMID 35798020 · DOI

The two doses did not give equivalent evidence

At 12 months, total hip bone mineral density had declined by 1.1% in controls and by 0.3% in the 50-gram group. The group-by-time comparison between these groups was statistically significant. The corresponding comparison between controls and the 100-gram group was not significant. It would therefore be inaccurate to summarize the experiment as showing an identical benefit at both doses, or to assume that doubling the quantity strengthened the result. The clearer comparison in the abstract concerns preservation of hip density with the lower prune assignment.

De Souza MJ, Strock NCA, Williams NI, Lee H, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2022. PMID 35798020 · DOI

Retention changes the reading

Overall dropout was 22%, but it was unevenly distributed: 41% in the 100-gram group, compared with 10% in controls and 15% in the 50-gram group. Reported compliance among the prune groups was high, approximately 90% and 87%, respectively. Compliance and retention answer different questions, so favorable compliance percentages should not hide the loss of participants. The high-dose dropout is part of the evidence, not a footnote to discard. It limits a simple dose-response story and helps explain why the lower-dose result deserves its own careful description.

De Souza MJ, Strock NCA, Williams NI, Lee H, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2022. PMID 35798020 · DOI

Density and predicted risk are not fractures counted

The abstract also reports changes in a calculated fracture-risk score, with maintenance in the pooled prune groups. Neither that score nor bone density is a count of hip fractures prevented during follow-up. The authors suggest possible fracture-risk benefit, but the measured findings support a narrower account of bone-density preservation. The linked breakfast uses fresh plums rather than the dried prunes tested here; it is a related fruit preparation, not a dose-equivalent intervention. This trial does not justify assigning its density result to that recipe or replacing osteoporosis treatment with fruit.

De Souza MJ, Strock NCA, Williams NI, Lee H, et al.. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 2022. PMID 35798020 · DOI