INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Blood pressure / Health Desk

Fruit, sweetened drinks, and blood pressure: the energy comparison matters

A controlled-feeding review found that food source and energy-control design changed the blood-pressure findings.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

Four comparisons, not one sugar question

This review separated four controlled-feeding designs rather than treating every sugar intervention as equivalent. Substitution trials exchanged sugars under energy-matched conditions; addition trials added excess energy from sugars. Subtraction trials removed excess energy from sugars, while ad libitum trials allowed energy from sugars to be freely replaced. The review included 93 reports covering 147 trial comparisons and 5,213 participants. Twelve food sources were assessed across those four energy-control levels. Those design labels are essential context for the blood-pressure findings: adding a source of sugar and exchanging it for another energy source were not the same experimental question.

Liu Q, Chiavaroli L, Ayoub-Charette S, Ahmed A et al.. PloS one, 2023. PMID 37582096 · DOI

The overall result needs its context

Total fructose-containing sugars had no effect on blood pressure in substitution, subtraction, or ad libitum trials. In addition trials, however, the pooled result showed decreases in both systolic and diastolic pressure, with P values below 0.05. Reading only that overall addition result would miss an important distinction in the abstract. The investigators found evidence that the food source influenced the response. Fruit and 100% fruit juice decreased pressure in addition trials, whereas mixed sources containing sugar-sweetened beverages increased it. The review therefore does not support treating fruit and sweetened drinks as interchangeable exposures simply because both contain sugars.

Liu Q, Chiavaroli L, Ayoub-Charette S, Ahmed A et al.. PloS one, 2023. PMID 37582096 · DOI

Removal results were source-specific too

In subtraction trials, removing sugar-sweetened beverages or mixed sources containing those beverages decreased blood pressure. The abstract describes a linear dose-response gradient for removing sugar-sweetened beverages. It also summarizes lower-dose fruit and 100% fruit juice exposures, up to approximately 10% of energy, separately from higher-dose mixed sources containing sweetened beverages, up to 23% of energy. These are descriptions of trial exposures, not instructions to add juice or calculate a sugar allowance. The study's main interpretive point is that both food source and energy control appear to mediate the measured response, rather than sugars having one uniform pressure effect.

Liu Q, Chiavaroli L, Ayoub-Charette S, Ahmed A et al.. PloS one, 2023. PMID 37582096 · DOI

Certainty and disclosures belong beside the result

The review searched databases through June 2021 and included controlled trials lasting at least seven days. Participants were adults with or without hypertension or at risk of it. The authors rated certainty as generally moderate using GRADE, so the findings should not be described as uniformly high-certainty evidence. The PubMed record also contains extensive competing-interest disclosures, including an author's fellowship jointly funded by the Government of Canada and the Canadian Sugar Institute. These disclosures are relevant context, not proof that a result is invalid. The measured outcomes were systolic and diastolic pressure; the abstract does not demonstrate fewer strokes or other cardiovascular events.

Liu Q, Chiavaroli L, Ayoub-Charette S, Ahmed A et al.. PloS one, 2023. PMID 37582096 · DOI