INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Gut Microbiome / Health Desk

Fructans and gluten: separating two suspects in a blinded challenge

A crossover trial found more symptoms with fructans than gluten in people reporting gluten sensitivity.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

What was actually separated

The trial asked a narrower question than whether wheat causes symptoms: could gluten and fructans produce different responses when tested separately? Investigators enrolled 59 people already following a self-instituted gluten-free diet, with celiac disease excluded. That selection matters because this was not a trial in people with celiac disease or a survey of everyone who eats wheat. Its purpose was to investigate self-reported non-celiac gluten sensitivity under blinded conditions. The findings therefore belong to that particular clinical question, rather than establishing a general reason to avoid wheat or a universal explanation for digestive symptoms.

Skodje GI, Sarna VK, Minelle IH, Rolfsen KL et al.. Gastroenterology, 2018. PMID 29102613 · DOI

A challenge with three conditions

Participants received gluten, fructans, and placebo in concealed muesli bars, completing all three challenges in a randomized, double-blind crossover design. Each challenge lasted seven days. The gluten condition supplied 5.7 grams and the fructan condition 2.1 grams; these are experimental amounts, not personal intake recommendations. Between challenges there was a washout of at least seven days, continuing until symptoms from the previous challenge resolved. Using the same participants across conditions made the comparison more focused than simply comparing people who choose different diets. Even so, a week-long challenge does not describe the consequences of years of eating a particular grain.

Skodje GI, Sarna VK, Minelle IH, Rolfsen KL et al.. Gastroenterology, 2018. PMID 29102613 · DOI

The group result favored a different explanation

Mean overall symptom scores were 33.1 during gluten, 38.6 during fructans, and 34.3 during placebo, with an overall comparison P value of .04. Higher scores represented more symptoms in this analysis. Fructans produced significantly higher overall scores than gluten, and the fructan-versus-gluten bloating comparison was also significant. Mean bloating scores were 9.3, 11.6, and 10.1 for gluten, fructans, and placebo, respectively. There was no difference in overall scores between gluten and placebo. The useful finding is this controlled contrast, not a claim that gluten can never be associated with symptoms in any individual or circumstance.

Skodje GI, Sarna VK, Minelle IH, Rolfsen KL et al.. Gastroenterology, 2018. PMID 29102613 · DOI

Individuals did not follow one script

The highest overall symptom score occurred after gluten in 13 participants, after fructans in 24, and after placebo in 22. Those counts keep the group result from becoming an overly simple label for every participant. A highest score in one challenge is also not the same thing as a validated diagnostic test. The abstract describes no biomarker for this disorder and reports symptom ratings during short challenges. Its conclusion supports fructans as a symptom-provoking component in this selected population, while the variation across all three conditions limits any attempt to identify one universal trigger from the average result alone.

Skodje GI, Sarna VK, Minelle IH, Rolfsen KL et al.. Gastroenterology, 2018. PMID 29102613 · DOI