INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Oncology / Health Desk

After colon cancer: an adverse Western-pattern signal is not proof of a plant-rich benefit

A survivor cohort found worse outcomes with a Western pattern, but no significant association for its prudent pattern.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

A dietary cohort inside a treatment trial

This prospective study followed 1,009 people with stage III colon cancer enrolled in an adjuvant chemotherapy trial. Participants reported dietary intake during chemotherapy and again six months afterward, using a semiquantitative food-frequency questionnaire. Although the parent trial randomized chemotherapy, this dietary analysis was observational: people were not assigned to the eating patterns being compared. That distinction prevents a common misreading of the study as a randomized diet trial. The outcomes were disease-free survival, recurrence-free survival and overall survival, making this a study of prognosis after diagnosis rather than the initial development of colon cancer.

Meyerhardt JA, Niedzwiecki D, Hollis D, Saltz LB et al.. JAMA, 2007. PMID 17699009 · DOI

What counted as prudent and Western

The researchers identified two major dietary patterns using factor analysis. Their prudent pattern included higher intakes of fruits and vegetables, but also poultry and fish. Their Western pattern included higher intakes of meat, fat, refined grains and dessert. Neither label describes a strictly vegan intervention, and the prudent pattern should not be silently renamed a whole-food plant-only diet. During a median 5.3 years of follow-up, 324 participants had a recurrence; 223 died with a recurrence, and 28 died without a documented recurrence. Those events formed the context for the subsequent survival comparisons.

Meyerhardt JA, Niedzwiecki D, Hollis D, Saltz LB et al.. JAMA, 2007. PMID 17699009 · DOI

The adverse Western-pattern association

Comparing the highest with the lowest fifth of Western-pattern intake, the adjusted hazard ratio for the disease-free-survival endpoint was 3.25, with a 95% confidence interval of 2.04–5.19. That endpoint included recurrence or death. The corresponding hazard ratios were 2.85 for recurrence-free survival and 2.32 for overall survival, with confidence intervals of 1.75–4.63 and 1.36–3.96 respectively. These are adjusted relative comparisons over follow-up, not absolute probabilities for a particular survivor. They describe a pattern-level association and cannot identify one ingredient as the cause of the observed differences in clinical outcomes over time.

Meyerhardt JA, Niedzwiecki D, Hollis D, Saltz LB et al.. JAMA, 2007. PMID 17699009 · DOI

The null finding belongs in the headline too

In contrast to the Western-pattern result, the prudent pattern was not significantly associated with recurrence or mortality. That finding blocks a tempting but unsupported reversal: an adverse association with one pattern does not prove a survival benefit from its presumed opposite. The authors called for further work to identify which components of the Western pattern had the strongest association. This cohort therefore supports a carefully bounded discussion of diet and prognosis in stage III colon cancer treated with surgery and chemotherapy. It does not establish that a plant-rich menu itself improved survival or that the same findings apply to every cancer diagnosis.

Meyerhardt JA, Niedzwiecki D, Hollis D, Saltz LB et al.. JAMA, 2007. PMID 17699009 · DOI